News · Hungary

Constitutional Court: immigration refusals based on classified data must disclose the essence of the reasons

In Decision 10/2026 (X. 8.) AB, promulgated in Magyar Közlöny No. 148 of 8 October 2026, Hungary's Constitutional Court annulled decisions of the National Directorate-General for Aliens Policing and of the courts in two immigration cases. In both cases the refusal rested on classified national-security data.

Promulgated: Published: Last checked:

Hungary
  • Constitutional Court
  • Immigration law

Summary

In brief

  • Decision 10/2026 (X. 8.) AB was published in Magyar Közlöny No. 148 of 8 October 2026.

  • In two immigration cases, authority and court decisions based on classified national-security data were annulled.

  • According to the Court, the right to fair administrative procedure is violated if the person concerned can learn neither the classified data nor the essence of the objections.

  • Full disclosure of classified data is not necessarily required, but the decision must state the essence of the reasons in a way that allows a defence, or another adequate safeguard must be provided.

  • A court's inspection of the classified file does not in itself replace the procedural rights of the person concerned.

Background

What happened

According to the table of contents of Magyar Közlöny, the decision found unconstitutional and annulled two judgments of the Budapest Környéki Törvényszék, judgment Kfv.III.37.798/2023/10 of the Kúria, and four decisions of the National Directorate-General for Aliens Policing and its Budapest and Pest County Regional Directorate.

According to the Közlöny summary on torvenyfigyelo.hu, the Court found that the right to fair administrative procedure is violated if the person concerned can learn neither the classified data nor the essence of the objections behind it, and therefore cannot make meaningful comments or a defence. The specialist-authority opinion and the immigration decision must, without harming the secrecy of the data, state the essence of the reasons in a way that allows a defence, or another adequate safeguard must be provided.

The Court rejected three complaints against the refusal of permission to access the data and one complaint against an order of the Kúria refusing admission, and dismissed the request to annul Section 11 of the Act on the protection of classified data (Mavtv.).

For you

What it means for you

  • Refused application: if your application was refused on the basis of a national-security specialist opinion and you could not learn the essence of the reasons, the decision may be relevant for a legal remedy; ask for a legal opinion on your specific case.
  • New applications: the decision does not change the requirements for residence permits; a complete, consistent application remains the most important factor.
  • Authority practice: there is no official information yet on how authorities will change the way they state reasons; we will report as soon as there is.

Programmes

Related programmes

  • Hungary

    Hungarian guest investor programme

    Hungary's guest investor programme grants a 10-year residence permit for investments starting at EUR 250,000, renewable for another 10 years.

    • Hungary
    • Investment
    • 10 years
  • Hungary

    Hungarian White Card

    The White Card is the residence permit for remote workers based in Hungary: 1 year, renewable once by 1 year.

    • Hungary
    • Remote work
    • Schengen
  • Hungary

    Long-term residence in Hungary

    After 3 years of legal residence in Hungary you can apply for a national residence card; after 5 years, for an EU residence card.

    • Hungary
    • Settlement
    • Indefinite stay

Request a quote

Planning to live in Hungary? We assess which permit fits you and prepare a complete application.

Request a quote